In the United States, approximately 2 million children under the age of 18 experience sports-related concussions annually. Concussions can have negative impacts on a child’s health, including physical, cognitive, emotional and sleep health. Between 2009 and 2014, all 50 states and the District of Columbia enacted concussion laws in an effort to raise awareness of symptoms and to reduce the risk of repeated concussions. These laws all include three elements: immediate removal from play, clearance by a health professional prior to a return to play, and mandatory concussion education for coaches, parents, and athletes. When these laws went into effect, an increase in concussions and concussion-related emergency visits occurred, most likely due to higher awareness and reporting. Over the following 2.6 years, rates of reported concussions decreased, suggesting improved concussion practices due to the enactment of the laws. Previous studies on the effectiveness of these laws have looked only at the existence of the concussion law. A new study investigated the association between multiple design elements of various state concussion laws and rates of new and recurrent sports-related concussions. Three design elements were examined: strength of law, number of law revisions, and speed of law adoption.
High School Report Information Online, a data collection tool that tracks sports-related injuries and athletic exposures (e.g. games or practice) among high school athletes, was used for this study. Data from the academic years 2009-2010 through 2016-2017 were used from the surveillance system to track concussions from a nationally representative sample of high school athletes.
Public Health Impact
Dawn Comstock, from the Colorado School of Public Health, along with colleagues from Ohio, Pennsylvania, Ireland and China, found over 7,000 sports-related concussions that occurred during the time period of the study at a rate of 39.7 sports-related concussions per 100,000 exposures. States with medium and high-strength laws were associated with higher rates of new concussion reporting. This suggests that stronger laws may be more effective in raising awareness of concussions and therefore increasing rates of reporting. Higher rates of new concussion reporting were also found in states with at least one law revision than in states with no law revisions. Recurrent concussion rates were lower in states with two or more law revisions than in state with less than two law revisions. Revisions to the laws could indicate a continued effort by lawmakers to increase the effectiveness of the law. Early adoption of state laws was associated with higher rates of new and recurrent concussion reporting, indicating the possibility of greater awareness of concussions and reporting. Overall, these findings could inform lawmakers of the nuances in the effectiveness of concussion laws.
April 30, 2024